WS · sample dossier
Worthington Steel, Inc.
44/100
OutdatedGenerated Oct 3, 2026 · 10:00 AM UTC · 1 hour ago
This copy is frozen (Oct 3). Sign in to run the same work — filings, valuation, bull and bear, sources — on any US stock or ETF, in about a minute.
Run a fresh dossierWS
EquityWorthington Steel, Inc.XNYS
Decision context
HOLD
Analysis horizon · 80% convictionA mixed picture — no strong reason to buy or sell right now.
The stock trades 104.0% above our estimated value range midpoint.
Current price
$36.97
Estimated value range
$18.12 – $29.38
Gap (vs midpoint)
-104.0%
The price is above our estimate, providing little valuation support.
Market context
Price
Price when available
Pick how far back the chart looks
1 month
+2.6%
3 months
+13.3%
6 months
+22.2%
1 year
+18.5%
Executive summary & thesis
Worthington Steel, Inc. operates as a steel processor with a market capitalization of $1.88B, trading at an EV/EBITDA of 10.25 and a conservative Debt/Equity ratio of 0.28.
- Top-line revenue expanded 11.6% YoY, demonstrating durable operational volume across core steel processing markets.
- Balance sheet solvency is solid, supported by a low Debt/Equity ratio of 0.28 and an Altman Z-score of 3.68.
- Cash flow conversion generated $1.60 in FCF per share, providing operational liquidity despite thin net margins.
- Earnings decayed severely with EPS growth plunging -189.1% YoY, elevating the trailing P/E multiple to 217.47.
- Profit conversion is weak with net margin at 0.2% and an operational Piotroski F-score of 3/9.
- The stock trades below its 200-day moving average, alongside insider sales of 21,607 shares on 2026-09-28.
Things to keep in mind
- 1Base target implies 51.0% downsideView source
- 2P/E 217.5xView source
- 3Net margin 0.2%View source
What to watch next
Factor profile
Balanced operator
| Factor | Score |
|---|---|
| Quality | 37 out of 100 (Weak). Business health — profits, returns, and consistency. Higher means a more durable company. |
| Growth | 22 out of 100 (Weak). How fast sales and earnings are rising. Higher means the business is expanding faster. |
| Value | 57 out of 100 (Neutral). How cheap the stock looks for what you get. Higher means a more attractive price. |
| Safety | 49 out of 100 (Neutral). Balance-sheet cushion and fewer red flags. Higher means less risk of a nasty surprise. |
| Momentum | 60 out of 100 (Neutral). Recent share-price trend. Higher means buyers have been in control lately. |
Another way to look at it
A calmer look at both sides of the Worthington Steel, Inc. story
The prevailing consensus fixates on the trough P/E multiple of 217.5 as an insurmountable valuation barrier, while simultaneously treating the 0.28 debt-to-equity ratio and $1.60 FCF per share as an unbreakable safety net.
Both views misdiagnose the underlying cyclical mechanics of steel processing. The Bear case overlooks that cyclical trough earnings artificially inflate trailing P/E multiples, mistaking temporary spread compression for structural obsolescence. Conversely, bulls ignore that a Piotroski F-score of 3/9 and razor-thin net margin of 0.2% signal severe operational decay, suggesting that positive FCF is likely working capital runoff rather than sustainable earning power. Relying on an Altman Z-score of 3.68 breeds complacency when gross margin sits at just 11.7% and EPS growth collapsed -189.1% YoY. With shares stuck below their 200-day moving average and EV/EBITDA at 10.2, the stock faces downside risk if cash conversion falters before operating margins recover.
Consensus relies on stale earnings data from May 31, 2026 (over 90 days old relative to the 2026-10-03 review date) that reported a diluted EPS loss of -$0.98, missing subsequent pricing spread developments.
The consensus uncritically accepts $1.60 to $1.78 in FCF per share as proof of resilience, failing to account for working capital liquidations that typically inflate cash flow during cyclical downturns while net margin sits at 0.2%.
Neither side reconciles the decoupling of 11.6% top-line revenue growth against a -189.1% EPS contraction, ignoring unhedged input cost inflation and margin compression across core processing lines.
Extrapolating 11.6% YoY revenue growth as commercial momentum when it failed to generate profitability, leaving net margins near breakeven at 0.2%.
Treating the Altman Z-score of 3.68 and Debt/Equity of 0.28 as definitive insulation against operational deterioration when gross margins are constrained at 11.7%.
Interpreting 6-month price returns of 22.2% as a confirmed structural breakout while the stock trades below its 200-day moving average and insider Clifford Larivey sold 21,607 shares on 2026-09-28.
Revenue growth YoY slows below 11.6% while gross margin contracts below 11.7%.
P/E ratio remains above 217.47 without an inflection in the 0.2% net margin.
Cash after investing
See whether Worthington Steel, Inc. still makes cash after it spends to grow.
- Revenue growth YoY slows below 11.6% while gross margin contracts below 11.7%.
- P/E ratio remains above 217.47 without an inflection in the 0.2% net margin.
- Net margin expands above 0.2% for two consecutive quarters
Monitor these triggers
Objective checkpoints to watch before the next earnings print
Net margin (current baseline: 0.2%) to confirm whether cost compression is reversing and restoring bottom-line profitability.
For learning and research only — not investment advice. AlphaDog doesn’t hold stocks and isn’t your financial advisor.
Run the next one yourself.
You just read a full WS dossier — scored verdict, valuation, and both sides, with sources. Sign in to run that on a name you hold, on current filings. A free account includes 10 credits a week, 1 per fresh run.